22,000 Records On Sale at the Rodgers and Hammerstein Archive of Recorded Sound August 8-10th

Vinyl fans began lining up at 8:00AM in front of the Lincoln Center Plaza home of the New York Public Library for the Performing Arts for a 22,000 LP sale. The records were culled from the collection of the Rodgers and Hammerstein Archive of Recorded Sound.

The records represent decades' worth of unsolicited donations made to the archives over the past few decades. The last such sale was held in 1984.

Of course I had to go. So I drove into New York City and arrived at 11:30AM. By that time the line stretched down the plaza and just before the doors opened it had gone much further back and well over a bridge leading to another section of the Lincoln Center Complex.

I ran into Jeff Joseph, of Joseph Audio who had arrived early in the morning. I didn't try to glom onto his spot on the line. When I returned to the end of the line I ran into a WNYC-FM intern reporter and asked for some microphone time. I hope what I said made it to air.

By the time I got into the sale there was not much worth buying. For one thing, Mr. Joseph the speaker designer had grabbed bags full of whatever good records were there, which was not too many. It was mostly very old mono classical records—not that there's anything wrong with those—but it was not what I was looking for though I did buy two mono Mercury Living Presence records just because they were there and so was I. Actually there were dozens of them and dozens of great RCA's—all mono.

I soon found out that the sale's organizers had let Academy Books and Records in a day early to pick through the collection and take much of the good stuff. Unfair! But I understand their point, which was that by doing that it helps support a good used book and record store.

New records are being brought out throughout the sale in order to let everyone have a chance to find some treasures. Friday they will be stocking the shelves with great titles from the Vanguard catalog and some others. Ditto Saturday, so it's all a matter of luck and timing.

I spied a box of what looked like "premium" records as I was paying a buck each for the two mono Mercs I'd bought and I asked about them. The guy guarding the front door said I could look through them and make offers on anything of interest. I found among a box of RCA Living Stereos and Mercury Living Presence treasures (most of which I already owned) a mint FR1 copy of Fiesta In Hi-Fi (Mercury SR90134), that I didn't as well as a Poulenc RCA Soria box that had been recorded in France. I made offers that were accepted for both and at least walked away with a few good scores, especially since Popsike.com has the Mercury recently selling for hundreds of dollars, which is far more than I paid for my copy!

So if you're in the upper West Side of Manhattan Friday or Saturday, pop in. You might find some great records. I wrote "might". I know you'll definitely find a lot of junk too!

COMMENTS
Brother John's picture

One of my best friends and fellow audiophiles works for Academy Records. He's an encyclopedia of music knowledge in charge of buying all their classical and jazz so even though I was a little ticked as well when I read your report I realized they work really hard in that store and need all the business they can get. I also find their prices quite fair considering present day Bloomberg NYC real estate market.

Jeffrey Lee's picture

Can't agree re: Academy. This was never billed as a "Come buy what Academy doesn't want sale." Strictly bush league cronyism.

marmaduke's picture

From where I am with no opportunity to attend, I can afford to be gracious.  However if I stood in line I would less than thrilled..

"You take what you need

And you leave the rest

But they should never

Have taken the very best"

May fit the situation somewhat.

eastwes's picture

Academy Records' prices range from fair to redicuolus.  In addition, one has to scrutinize the condition of the vinyl they sell...

Yet another gripe I have with Academy is their practice of auctioning off certain choice findings via eBay, in the process preventing their walk-in patrons from purchasing onsite.  Considering that many of us have been loyal customers over the years, this is a kick in the face...

Letting a commercial business in to peruse and cherrypick a day prior to opening the doors to the unsuspecting vinyl enthusiasts also looking for a gem or two is just plain WRONG!  

DJ Huk's picture

I'll never forget the record sale they had here in Chicago at the Harold Washington Library several years ago.  All these pristine barely used classical records and one Krautrock original in beautiful shape.  Makes you wonder if they have any other goodies lurking somewhere in some obscure corner.  

volvic's picture

WAs upset I couldn't go yesterday and finally went there today, was lame and I left after perusing for a few minutes. Had I known that Academy cleaned house I wouldn't have made my way.  Agree about Academy prices lately bordering on the ridiculous for vinyl and cd's, and quality of their vinyl hasn't been great either as of late.  Other record stores in other cities were rent is high offer reasonable prices and better quality. Might make a day trip next Friday.  

Blue Note's picture

Michael, so say near the end of the recording "look at all the old people..."  What I see doesn't look much like old people, older perhaps, but it looks like mostly around 30ish, is that correct?

Michael Fremer's picture

I meant that as sarcasm..... yes, not many old people! That was the point, perhaps not delivered with sufficient sarcasm!

volvic's picture

Forgot to mention in my rant from above, that I was surprised to see so many young people A) buying vinyl and B) Looking at the Opera and Classical music bins.  There is still hope for humanity.  

X